Slice 3b task 2 (D8/C10-C12). New OpenNest.Engine.Jobs.ClampRemovalRecovery:
after the ordinary clamped solve leaves demand unmet, probes (via the
caller's own selected engine, quantity one, one fresh empty sheet)
whether each unplaced part fits on any offered stock with every clamp
in place; only a part that fits nowhere is 'blocked' (C10). For a
blocked part, searches ascending run size then ascending start index
over each stock's own clamp zones (already rail-position order) for
the smallest contiguous run whose removal lets it fit alone - fewest
clamps first, nearest the origin on ties (C11). Builds reduced-clamp
stock variants for every resolved (part, stock), re-solves the whole
residual demand (so freed space can also take other unmet parts, C12)
with original stock carried forward minus phase 1's usage (a finite
pool is never offered both full and reduced, so it is never double
counted) and merges the result back: phase 2 placements get fresh
instance indices continuing from phase 1's, plates are reindexed, and
fulfillment/stock usage are recomputed. Returns null (no-op) whenever
the job is already complete, no stock has any clamp, no remaining
part is genuinely blocked, or even every clamp removed cannot fit a
blocked part - so an ordinary job is bit-identical to Slice 3 (C10's
last sentence).
NestPipeline.RunCore calls it once, right after the main solve, only
on the non-cutout-preview path; a recovery replaces 'raw' and expands
'job' (adding exactly the reduced-clamp variants used) before the
existing validation/cost/grouping/binding code runs unchanged.
NestPipelineCommit.SyncClampZones now derives which rail clamps (if
any) are missing from a committed sheet's solved zones and, when the
rail recreates exactly that reduced set, reattaches the rail with
Plate.SetClampRail(rail, removedClamps) - so a recovered sheet keeps
following the rail, minus its removal, through later resizes (C13),
using Slice 3b task 1's plumbing.
Tests: 7 new (OpenNest.Engine.Tests/Jobs/ClampRemovalRecoveryTests.cs,
ClampRemovalCommitTests.cs) covering the minimal-removal + nearest-
origin tie-break, freed space taking other residual demand (C12), a
no-op on an already-complete job, no-op with no clamps offered, a
part blocked only by stock exhaustion never being treated as clamp-
blocked, a part unfit even clamp-free staying unplaced, and the full
Auto-Nest-to-commit path keeping Plate.RemovedClamps/ClampRail/
ClampRemovalMinutes correct through a resize. Mutation checks
(disabling the FitsAnywhere gate; reversing the ascending-start tie-
break) turn the relevant assertions red, confirming real coverage.
Gates: Release OpenNest.Tests 3884 passed/31 skipped, OpenNest.IO.Tests
105 passed, OpenNest.Engine.Tests 878 passed/2 skipped; desktop
cross-build (-p:EnableWindowsTargeting=true) clean; scoped dotnet
format --verify-no-changes clean.
Desktop surface (removed-clamp display, Auto Nest summary, cut-time
minutes, Clamps dialog removal-minutes field) is Slice 3b task 3, not
yet done.
A clamp is an avoidance area, so a clamp that only partly reaches a
sheet (for example centered at 60.5" on a 60" sheet, or near the
origin) now keeps its whole 1.5" x 0.625" footprint instead of being
clipped to the sheet; clamps wholly beyond the sheet are still left
off. Job validation accepts a zone that hangs past the sheet edges and
still rejects one that does not reach the sheet at all. Both packing
lanes already block keep-outs extending past the bin; a hanging-clamp
solve through Rectangles, Irregular and Default keeps every part clear
of the whole inflated footprint.
User decision 2026-10-12, settling the plan's pending D2 question.
Plan Cutting previews were built without the plate's clamp zones, so
machine clamps disappeared from the canvas while inspecting a proposal.
Copy the plate's immutable zones onto the detached preview; it does not
follow the rail, so it never re-resolves.
Review finding 8, Project Memory 4e5f566d.
When a commit installed solved explicit zones on a plate that followed
a different nest clamp rail (an extra sheet created from the defaults),
the plate kept the rail, so a later Size or Quadrant assignment (Edit
Plate assigns Size even when unchanged) or a stock-option build swapped
the validated zones for the rail's clamps. Install solved zones as
explicit zones and keep the rail only when it recreates them.
Review finding 1, Project Memory 4e5f566d-626e-4db5-9352-14ddd9051181.
When the Auto Nest template plate follows the machine clamp rail, offer
each plate-size option with the rail resolved for that size instead of
copying the template's zones: a shorter option no longer carries clamps
beyond its end (which job validation rejected), a longer one gets the
clamps past the template's length, and sheets extending to negative X
keep their clamps measured from the origin. Templates with explicit
zones and no rail are offered unchanged.
ApplyToEmptyPlates copied size, spacing, quadrant and quantity from the
solved stock but not its clamp zones, so a sheet the commit created had
no keep-outs although its parts were validated against them, and a
reused plate could keep zones the layout was not solved with.
Map the stock's placement-frame zones back to plate coordinates on every
committed plate; zones already equal in the placement frame are left
untouched so an unchanged plate raises no change events.
Project Memory: bcc2dd2a-2ab6-4a2a-9c13-197e0aeb24bc
Block each clamp's keep-out into the max-rects free list before any
packing: same split logic as placements, not a used item (no contact
score, no material). The blocked rectangle accounts for the inflated
item model exactly - material keeps the bottom-edge clearance from the
clamp without paying an extra part-spacing tax; degenerate spans
collapse to the zone centerline (conservative, never permissive).
Zero-clamp sheets skip blocking entirely: three fixture layout hashes
(rectangle grid, mixed shapes, multi-sheet overflow), captured from the
unchanged packer at a3f1124, stay bit-identical (C2). With clamps:
placements never intrude, demand lands between two clamps when it fits,
a full-width front rail makes an otherwise feasible job Incomplete, and
a far-away zone leaves the layout hash equal to no-clamps.
Rectangles lane only; Irregular parity is Slice 2.
NestPlateStock takes an optional clamp-zone list, translated into the
placement frame exactly like WorkArea (quadrants 1-4) and detached from
caller boxes; empty input keeps stock bit-identical to before. Plate
mappings (DrawingJobMapper.FromPlate/CreatePlate, NestStockBuilder) map
zones across; materialized plates carry them for checking.
NestJobValidator rejects zones outside the sheet or duplicate ids.
RepeatedPlateGrouping and NestLayoutCheck treat clamp sets as stock
identity (C8), and the layout checker flags part material inside a zone
inflated by bottom-edge spacing with the shared spacing slack (C1/C5) -
no tolerance loosened.
Nests converted from another CAM system carry its seam overcut inside the
clean contour: the last cut runs on past the contour's own start along its
first cut, then a straight jog returns to the start. The ring then touches
itself at its seam, so neither the cutting planner nor the overlap analyzer
could certify it and the whole plate refused.
SeamOvercut recognizes exactly that shape (same line, or same circle and
direction) and trims it from an owned copy; the retraced tail encloses no
area, so material is unchanged and the drawing is never edited. Any other
self-contact still refuses. Arcs of one circle whose centers were each derived
from their own endpoints agree only within Epsilon, so their spans are now
compared at the seam tolerance: shared spans still refuse as overlap, while
arcs that only meet at a joint or lie apart no longer do.
Plates with parts nested in other parts' cutouts then failed to route, since
the host is cut last and every straight approach from the middle of a crowded
cutout crosses a finished neighbour. CuttingNestedOrder tours each host's
inner parts as one run ending beside the host's own contours, hosts follow
the parts beside them, and learned rules still win. Outside entries are
ordered by clear sight lines to the next cut, the look-ahead toward a host is
its nearest contour point rather than its centre, a cutout containing the
arrival point is routed from that point, and a pass that teaches an order
rule ends the round instead of repeating the blocked approach.
Tests: SeamOvercutTests and CuttingNestedOrderTests; the cutting-planning,
diagnostics and overlap tests in OpenNest.Tests pass (1023 passed, 6 skipped).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Report, dialog and diagnostic text across post verification, cutoff
planning, alignment and cutting-plan review repeatedly told the user
what checks weren't (safety certifications, proof, guarantees) instead
of what to do. Reworded these to state the same caveats affirmatively
(inspect X, confirm Y, review Z) without changing the underlying
safety guidance, and updated the tests/docs that pinned the old wording.
PreferredContourEntries resolves one entry per hole by walking the
proposed hole route BACKWARD from the already-chosen perimeter entry.
Each hole ranks against the downstream contour's ACTUAL emitted pierce
(first non-rapid motion of the owned probe emission, native rounding
included), so the cut chain flows toward the outside start rather than
chaining on nominal points that rounding may move.
Catalogue is the S04 merged list (preferred kinds where present,
compass/arc fallbacks otherwise — pure circles included); ordering is
the S05 facing/tier/travel ranker; feasibility is one S08-bounded pick
per hole through caller-supplied S07 verdicts. A hole with no feasible
candidate yields an explicit no-preference proposal naming the contour
and reason — never a silent skip, never a partial chain. Arrival proxies
(part arrival for the first hole, previous hole centre otherwise) keep
the pass deterministic and circularity-free.
Deterministic (repeat runs identical), cancellation-aware, ownership-
checked, source program untouched, fresh owned probe programs only.
This is a recommended-v1 proposal: nothing is installed into the search
and no rapid is certified here — S12 wires it and must handle a blocked
preferred rapid.
Tests: circle pair flows hole->hole->outside via actual pierces (each
pierce strictly nearer downstream than the opposite compass pierce);
rectangular holes pick right-facing corners under all-clear evaluation;
blocked ideal candidate falls back to next-ranked on the same hole;
blocked hole yields honest no-preference finding; permutation integrity
in route order excluding the perimeter; determinism; foreign perimeter
refused; cancellation; fingerprint/ownership/fresh-program invariants.
Gate 9/0/0; full Core 3580/25skip/0; cross-build 0 errors; scoped
format verify 0; facing-drop and silent-skip mutants killed; nominal-
vs-actual-pierce mutant documented near-equivalent.
CuttingHoleOrder proposes the cut order of a part's remaining holes as
an OPEN path arrival -> every hole centre exactly once -> the fixed
perimeter entry, reusing CuttingPartOrder's bounded nearest-neighbour +
2-opt/Or-opt machinery (no exhaustive permutations, no new routing
invention). A proposal only: the search still certifies every rapid and
emitted lead; nothing is installed into the search yet.
CuttingPartOrder gains an optional endpoint: the terminal edge joins
EVERY improvement delta (2-opt tail edge on both sides; OrOpt gap to the
open end measures the endpoint distance), so heuristics see route moves
that re-point the path at the entry rather than only final scoring. No
endpoint keeps whole-part semantics byte-identical (control test);
precedence, prerequisites and tie policy unchanged.
Tests: empty/one hole; asymmetric fixture where the endpoint changes the
ORDER (open route ends at C, entry-facing route ends at B) with each
route asserted equal to its brute-force optimum computed from
coordinates; permutation integrity excluding the perimeter; random 7-set
within 1.05x brute force; deterministic tie order; cancellation; legacy
no-endpoint equality. Mutants dropping the terminal edge from OrOpt or
TwoOpt deltas are killed.
No-hole parts now choose the outside entry through the S03-S08 pipeline
at the part boundary: rank the native catalogue toward the NEXT cut's
placed-material centre, lazily certify each emitted lead with the shared
validator, cap at maxEntries with side coverage. The next cut is the
next unfinished part on the supplied order (re-read after every
learned-order replan) or, in sequence-free fallback, the nearest
dependency-ready remaining part with stable ordinal ties; the last part
has no target and ranks by tier then arrival distance — never the plate
origin. Target and arrival are converted to prepared LOCAL coordinates
exactly once; geometry is already rotated.
The look-ahead rank survives Follow's ordering: children sort by
nearest source first (the sequence-free tour stays nearest-first), then
contour, then the selection rank — plain OrderBy(Distance) can no longer
undo the facing. Measured fixture (three squares, 0.15 leads, origin
start): legacy cut every sheet at its arrival-nearest lower-left corner
with 10.5-unit cross-sheet rapids totalling 21.0; look-ahead cuts the
+X-facing corner with the same 21.0 total but each inter-part rapid now
starts at the facing edge instead of trailing across the whole sheet.
Uncertain validator answers are never precheck-refused: they skip the
selected slots but flow to the emitted-prefix Check and complete replay,
which stay the authority — a refused-looking incomplete is reported,
not hidden. A fully evaluated catalogue with no fitting lead surfaces
'No tested lead-in fits on part N, contour M'; budget exhaustion stays a
budget finding. Lead prechecks count separately from DFS expansions; the
pipeline itself is one counted expansion per contour. Full backtracking,
dependencies, locked/fixed programs, cutoff handling, emitted-prefix
Check and complete replay are unchanged; budgets and CuttingPartOrder
untouched. Hole parts keep the legacy path until S12.
aj
