A cutout cut in several pieces around tabs, as PEP programs often are, made
pre-post review report every piece's lead-out and the part's open fragments
as incomplete. Review now proves such open cuts release nothing: within the
part they touch other cuts only at their own ends and form no loop (each
closed contour with its leads counting as one point), and leads at open ends
stay out of the gap beyond them. Anything else stays incomplete. Plan Cutting
keeps refusing to certify its own tabs followed by a lead-out.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Posting review now proves containment exactly as the cutting planner does
(shared NestedPartContainment) and warns when a nested part is cut after its
host (NestedCutOrder) or when a host's hole lead or the nested part's lead
meets the other's material (NestedLead), including subprogram hole poses.
Ambiguous containment is incomplete, never clear; fixed-lead motions are not
reported twice. A committed cutout preview warns until Plan Cutting cuts the
insert first.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The spec review found two places where the marker and threshold
contract does not hold.
A clamp narrower than the chord tolerance is still judged
tolerance-free against finely re-read material and reported as the
whole clamp rectangle. That existing safety policy is kept, so its
marker is the clamp's centre: within half the clamp's size (under
0.0005) of the material, though not necessarily on it. Document this
on PlateOverlapPair.Marker and in the overlap docs, and lock it in the
tiny-clamp region test.
Also document that 1e-8 grid rounding can move an area within
rounding error of the 1e-5 threshold to either side of it.
The overlap crosshair sat on the pair's area centroid. For a split,
holed or concave overlap, that point can be off the red material:
between two patches, in a hole, or inside a curve.
PlateOverlapPair.Marker is a point inside the pair's largest island.
It is the island's pole of inaccessibility (PolyLabel), searched to a
tenth of the island's area/perimeter within a 4096-cell budget. If
that bounded search does not land inside (a long thin sliver), the
marker falls back to the midpoint of the widest interior run of a
horizontal scan line placed between vertex heights.
The overlay crosshair, marker hit testing, hover coordinates
("Marker:") and the cutting-inspection ring now use the marker.
Centroid stays the true area centroid. View > Overlap Check > Display
> Centroids is now labelled Markers.
Before the marker existed, its call sites used the centroid. Two
patches, a covered frame, a half annulus and a thin crescent then put
it off the material; now all four land on it. Disabling the scan-line
fallback fails its test. On the 389-plate corpus, markers add about
0.4 ms per overlapping pair; pair and area results are unchanged.
The material-overlap diagnostic clipped every triangle of one part
against every triangle of the other, then carved each fragment by
every hole triangle. Curved overlaps produced thousands of fragments,
and a part sitting inside another part's cutout was slow even when
clear.
PlateOverlapAnalyzer now intersects each candidate pair's hole-aware
material once with Clipper2, in part-local coordinates on a 1e-8 grid.
Each operand is its outline minus the union of its holes (positive
fill rule). Regions become connected islands: a counterclockwise
outline plus clockwise Holes, including an island that both parts'
holes enclose together. PolygonAreaMoments.TrySubtract gives each
island's net moments. A pair is reported when its total shared area
exceeds Tolerance.Epsilon. Out-of-range or nonfinite coordinates make
the pair incomplete rather than clear. The overlay and the cutting
inspection highlight fill outlines with their holes.
On 389 real PEP-converted plates the pair, clamp-finding and issue
sets are identical to the previous kernel. Pair areas are equal or up
to 0.0002 larger: the kernel drops fragments below its area threshold.
With material prepared, the per-plate clipping maximum fell from
2.6 s to 52 ms (total 5.0 s to 0.5 s).
Engine and validation checks still use Collision.
PlateOverlapRegion vertices repeat their closing vertex, and the
desktop overlay drops that last vertex when it builds the fill path.
The tolerance-free tiny-clamp finding returned four open corners, so
the overlay drew it as a triangle. Close the ring like every other
region.
Check Overlaps dismissed a tiny clamp by the part's coarse material bounds
before the fine tolerance-free test ran, but that material is inscribed at
the 0.001 chord tolerance: real material in the sliver beyond a convex arc
(a short arc cap, a rotated crescent) lay outside those bounds and the clamp
read as clear. For clamps below the tolerance the bounds are widened by the
chord tolerance before rejecting.
PM 407f5eb7-329f-41e4-947e-64ad52aa4034 (review s6-delta3-review.md)
Circumscribing every arc holds all material along convex arcs but drops a
sliver along concave ones (a notch), so a tiny clamp 6e-7 into the material
beside a notch read as clear. Tiny-clamp checks now test the part flattened
both ways (all arcs inscribed, all arcs circumscribed): along any arc one of
the two holds the real material, so together they find every real overlap.
PM 407f5eb7-329f-41e4-947e-64ad52aa4034 (delta review s6-delta2-review.md)
Fine inscribed flattening still let a native arc cut 6.2e-7 into a 1e-5
clamp unseen: less than one chord's sag, so the layout check, interactive
fill and Check Overlaps all called it clear. Tiny-clamp checks now
circumscribe perimeter arcs and inscribe cutout arcs (lines stay exact), so
the polygons hold every bit of real material. Any real overlap is reported;
the cost is a possible report within the tolerance of an arc, never a false
clear. The analyzer builds the same polygons instead of a second
OverlapMaterial read.
PM 407f5eb7-329f-41e4-947e-64ad52aa4034 (delta review s6-delta-review.md)
The tolerance-free rectangle test was fed approximated material: the layout
check passed it the 1e-4-grid validation outline (a strip of real material
that wholly contains a 1e-5 clamp could vanish), and interactive fill and
the overlap check passed 0.001 inscribed arc chords (a clamp inside a disk
but outside its chords read as clear). All three now flatten the native
contours at a quarter of the clamp's smaller side, lines kept exact, so the
arc-chord sliver can never hold the clamp. Ordinary clamps are unchanged.
PM 407f5eb7-329f-41e4-947e-64ad52aa4034
Collision.Check finds no overlap region for a clamp smaller than its
tolerance, so Check Overlaps reported a part covering a 1e-5 clamp as clear.
Clamps below 0.001 are judged with KeepOutOverlap and reported as a finding
whose fragment is the whole clamp rectangle; flush and clear parts stay clear.
PM aa995123-295f-479c-adc4-b0cbcb7cf838
D10 (user decision 2026-10-13, keep the warning): a clamp footprint covering
the modeled program start (0,0) makes the first rapid of every posting attempt
cross it, and that warning has no exemption and no persisted bypass. Lock the
behavior in all four quadrants with a physical-footprint oracle and a mutation
red (skipping rapids that start inside a zone reddens exactly the four
origin-covering rows). Document the design in docs/post-verification.md.
The desktop captures the overlap freshness stamp before its error
boundary, and a null cut-off or clamp zone in the plate's lists threw
NullReferenceException there. Stamp missing entries as a distinct empty
state so the whole-plate capture can report the malformed input as a
failed check instead.
Project Memory: opennest cdbe2629-b562-46ee-9509-2b120a511654
Pre-post clamp checks looked only at nominal cut-off definitions and
rapids. A definition moved without regenerating its placed program
left a cut through an active clamp that posted with no warning, because
cut-off material is excluded from the overlap check.
Also check each cut-off part's placed cutting motions against the
clamps in the placement frame (lines exactly, arcs by their extent).
Report one warning per cut-off part and clamp, so a current definition
does not produce a duplicate of its nominal finding.
Project Memory: opennest cdbe2629-b562-46ee-9509-2b120a511654
Plate.ClampZones are stored relative to the sheet's lower-left corner,
but cut-off positions, motions and part poses use the signed quadrant
frame. The automatic cutoff planner, manual cut-off contacts, clamp
rapid warnings and whole-plate overlap capture compared the two
directly, so in quadrants 2-4 a cut or rapid through a real rail clamp
was neither avoided nor warned about.
Add ClampZoneFrame.ToPlacement, which maps live zones into the
placement frame exactly like the sheet and engine stock, and use it in
every Slice 5 consumer. It rejects missing or malformed zones (bounds
stay publicly mutable); pre-post verification reports those as an
incomplete clamp check instead of a clear result. Overlap freshness now
treats a size or quadrant change as moving the zones.
Tests use real ClampRail zones in all quadrants; the hand-signed
quadrant fixtures that hid the defect are converted to rails.
Project Memory: opennest 274836d5-fb76-4619-b3cc-0c811e767dd6
Report, dialog and diagnostic text across post verification, cutoff
planning, alignment and cutting-plan review repeatedly told the user
what checks weren't (safety certifications, proof, guarantees) instead
of what to do. Reworded these to state the same caveats affirmatively
(inspect X, confirm Y, review Z) without changing the underlying
safety guidance, and updated the tests/docs that pinned the old wording.
1b422ef read absolute-mode hole subprograms by converting an
incremental-mode copy of every clean program. Rebuilding absolute
endpoints from incremental deltas is not exact: after a rapid at
1e12 a 1x10 rectangle moved by about 2.4e-5 and a real 2e-5 overlap
was reported clear, in the overlap overlay and pre-post verification
as well as Plan Cutting.
Convert programs directly again, which reads absolute coordinates
exactly, and refuse an absolute-mode subprogram as an incomplete
check instead: the converter adds a call's frame offset to
incremental moves only, so it would read such a hole at its frame
origin. OpenNest writes hole subprograms in incremental mode. The
null-list and unknown-instruction refusals from 1b422ef stay, and
CopyForGeometry is private to the planner again.
PlateOverlapAnalyzer converted clean programs directly with
ConvertProgram.ToGeometry, which adds call offsets only to
incremental moves, so holes in absolute-mode subprograms were read at
their frame origin. A square with two absolute holes reported
"Native material contours cross or touch", and the Plan Cutting
overlap gate blocked it while the incremental twin passed. Convert an
owned incremental-mode copy instead (PreparedContours.CopyForGeometry,
now internal, the same normalization the cutting planner uses).
The analyzer also threw on a program whose Codes list was null and
cast or cloned instructions it does not know. It now refuses a
missing list and anything other than the exact built-in instruction
types as an incomplete check, before any copy or conversion runs.
Pre-post verification and the plate overlap overlay share this path.
Nest windows now rerun the overlap check once the layout has been
unchanged for 0.5 s, instead of leaving 'Overlaps: not checked'. Edits
show 'Overlaps: check pending...'; drags are caught by the paint-time
pose stamp, collection edits by their events. The check waits while a
mouse button, modal dialog or fill is active, supersedes a running check
when the layout moves again, and does not retry a canceled or failed
layout until it changes. Rechecks use the incremental analyzer, so only
the moved parts' neighbors are recomputed.
Automatic results update only the canvas label (the status bar keeps the
last command's message) and keep Display > Off. Check Active Plate still
runs immediately. InvalidateOverlapCheck now also drops cached material.
PlateOverlapAnalyzer.Capture(parts, OverlapMaterialCache) reuses each clean
program's converted entities and prepared material across requests, and
Analyze(snapshot, previous) reuses pair results whose two parts kept the
same source, exact pose and relative order, renumbering them. A recheck
after moving one part only clips that part's neighbors again.
On 501 real PEP plates: full check median 1 ms / max 6.4 s; incremental
recheck after one move median 0.1 ms / max 38 ms. Incremental results
matched uncached full analysis exactly across 2505 edits.
ajandClaude Opus 5.5